Blog

Cairo Says AU summit in Addis Ababa ignores Nile dam crisis.

The 35th African Union Summit was held in Addis Ababa to discuss peace and security issues in Africa but the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam was not on the agenda according to Al-Monitor report.

Even as negotiations on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam Gerd remain stalled the 35th African Union AU Summit was held on February 5 to 6 at AU headquarters in Addis Ababa.

The summit did not tackle the GERD crisis which has been strongly disputed between Cairo Khartoum and Addis Ababa for more than a decade in Africa.

Heads of states and governments from the 55 AU member states participated in the summit’s meetings including Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry. 

The agenda of the summit focused on African peace and security related issues and the repeated military cous in Africa. 

Four coups occurred within 10 months in the western part of the continent including in Burkina Faso, Mali and Guinea as well as a failed coup in Niger.

Egyptians counted only the west African coups but ignored the east African cous including the Sudanese.

Is this a deliberate or any reason for not mentioning the cou of Abdel Fattah al-Burhan?

That is right! Al-Burhan has been an intimate friend of Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi and it’s obvious that the Sudanese military government has been a right hand for Egypt.

African coups are being mentioned here from their negative perspectives and hence including the Sudanese incidence doesn’t make sense for Egypt as an ally of the generals.

Thanks for that Malcolm. Pleasure!

Let’s resume from the report.

The agenda of AU Summit also included the repercussions of COVID-19 the member states’ positions on the decision to grant Israel official observer status at the African Union, migration, poverty and economic integration. 

Meanwhile the AU summit unanimously voted to suspend the decision to grant Israel observer status in the pan-African organization.

It also announced the formation of a committee of seven countries to examine this decision including current A you chair Senegal and Algeria which strongly opposes this decision.

Commenting on why the Gerd crisis was not discussed at the summit even though it was held in Addis Ababa, which is a party to the crisis and even though Cairo took part in the committee’s meetings, Mohamed al-Orabi an Egyptian parliament member and a former foreign minister told Al-Monitor that the 35th AU summit was not supposed to discuss the Gerd issue and the dam crisis was not on the agenda. 

Hence Egypt was not expecting the Gerd crisis to be discussed at the summit he said, adding that the summit meetings are not the right place to discuss such a major crisis which is a matter of life and death for both Egypt and Sudan.

Come on Egypt, says Malcolm! There is no such thing as life and death. The Gerd project builds the lives of many not causing deaths. In fact it saves the lives of several people suffering from seasonal flood in Sudan. Sudan is the major and the instant beneficiary of the completion of Gerd project.

If Egypt is nervous or worrying too much about the water shortage due to Gerd then it has to find alternative solutions for the death prediction.

Ethiopia doesn’t see any such problem to happen in Egypt because of the Gerd. The water continues to flow down to Sudan and Egypt as usual after hitting the turbines

The reservoir and dam will offer major benefits to Ethiopia, Egypt and Sudan. Egypt has for a long time held the major ownership of the water from the Nile River and prevented Ethiopia from constructing a dam. Egypt even has to pay the compensation to Ethiopia for preventing or for its deliberate negative perception towards the project for such a long period. Egypt’s economy is more than three fold of Ethiopia’s mainly because of the America’s dollar inflow into its economy without any sanction imposition for its intermediary role between the Israeli and Arab matters. The people of Ethiopia has the right to have access to electricity and the country needs to lift its population out of poverty.

Thanks for your intervention Malcom!

Orabi added “Cairo is counting on Senegal in its capacity as AU president to play a major role in bringing the Gerd file to the dialogue and negotiations table and to come up with a mechanism for an agreement that meets the demands of the three parties to the crisis.

The AU summit is not concerned with discussing the Gerd crisis and is not able to bring positive results in this file.

Only general discussions of some general and outstanding issues related to Africa were held during the meetings at the summit.”

In his closing remarks at the AU summit Senegalese President Macky Sall said that Africa will no longer accept military coups in some African countries and noted that the challenges facing the AU are related to peace, security, stability, combating terrorism and countering the military coups in Africa.

Orabi explained that the Gerd issue is a priority for the A you chair, which is Senegal in cooperation with other countries of major influence in the AU such as Algeria and they are both working to resume talks on the GERD. 

He noted that the Ethiopian Foreign Ministry’s recent remarks that the Sudanese side is not dealing with the GERD file based on Khartoum’s interests but rather to the advantage of a third party (in reference to Egypt) is an Ethiopian attempt to divide the unified Cairo and Khartoum position that rejects Addis Ababa’s unilateral filling of the dam’s reservoir. 

In a February 12, 2022 televised statement Sherif el-Gabaly head of the Egyptian parliamentary African Affairs Committee said the Gerd issue will be resolved sooner or later, adding that Egypt is in good standing in Africa as the Egyptian policy is strongly oriented toward Africa.

In this context, Orabi said “The Ethiopian side believes that dividing the Egyptian-Sudanese position is the first step toward progress in the Gerd file. Yet the two countries are well aware of these malicious attempts that seek to drive a wedge between the two countries. These malicious attempts prove that Addis Ababa has no serious intention for progress to resume negotiations and reach a binding legal agreement that meets the aspirations of the three parties to the crisis.”

He added, “The Ethiopian side has been prevaricating and buying more time and has no intention to engage in serious talks. That is why we do not trust the Ethiopian side in reaching a binding agreement. This prevarication that has been going on for a decade has been the biggest obstacle to the success of any negotiation attempts or attempts to resume them.”

Egypt’s close involvement in the internal matter of Ethiopia and supporting the terrorist TPLF is not mentioned as malicious here. Interesting!

We don’t think what Egypt stating about Ethiopia is true according to Malcom. It’s not the question of dividing both leaders of Egypt and Sudan. But Ethiopia has a genuine point to make here.

Since the start of the Gerd the Sudan’s rhetoric about the dam has moved from being broadly welcoming to being suspicious and belligerent. Why? Ethiopia sees the reason behind such a move coming solely from Egypt.

Ethiopia has no problem with either Sudan or its people but puppet military government. It looks like Sudan is under the Egyptian colony currently. The Sudanese are crying day and night with vain as the cou government is not listening the voices of its own people.

Thanks for that.

Salah Halima former assistant foreign minister in Egypt said that the Gerd file was transferred to Senegal after the latter was handed the AU presidencyand that regional and international efforts are currently being exerted to push forward the negotiation process. 

Meanwhile Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan held in late January and early February separate meetings with Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and General Mohamed Hamdan Daglo deputy chairman of Sudan’s Sovereignty Council. 

Commenting on those meetings Halima said the Emirati crown prince’s meetings come as part of international moves to push for the resumption of the Gerd negotiations. He mentioned similar moves by Saudi Arabia the United States and China. 

Halima also condemned Ethiopia’s attempts to drive a wedge between Cairo and Khartoum in reference to the Ethiopian Foreign Ministry’s statement on Sudan working to the advantage of a third party rather than for its own interests. He said such attempts are unsuccessful and will not lead to any progress because both countries are well aware of how dangerous Ethiopia’s unilateral actions on the Gerd are.

Halima continued “Egypt is counting on Senegal to play a pivotal role in resuming the Gerd negotiations, particularly since Senegal had a similar experience during a conflict over the Senegal River Basin countries.”

Watch the video on our YouTube Channel here